JOURNAL EDITORIAL POLICIES
Peer Review Policy
Principles, standards, and ethical responsibilities governing the peer review of manuscripts submitted to Dirasah: International Journal of Islamic Studies.
 

Dirasah: International Journal of Islamic Studies is committed to maintaining the quality and integrity of scholarly publishing through a fair, objective, and rigorous peer review system. This policy establishes the standards, responsibilities, and ethical principles that guide the evaluation of manuscripts submitted to the journal.

DOUBLE-BLIND PEER REVIEW
Each manuscript is evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant academic expertise. The identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process.
CONTENTS
  1. General Peer Review Policy
  2. Peer Review Model
  3. Reviewer Selection and Qualifications
  4. Review Criteria
  5. Editorial Decisions
  6. Confidentiality and Ethical Responsibilities
  7. Conflict of Interest
  8. Review Timeliness
  9. Plagiarism and Research Integrity
  10. Appeals and Complaints
  11. Post-Review Revisions
  12. Final Authority and Policy Implementation

01. General Peer Review Policy

All manuscripts submitted to Dirasah are subject to editorial assessment and peer review before a final publication decision is made. The journal applies a double-blind peer review system involving at least two independent reviewers who possess expertise relevant to the manuscript.

The peer review process aims to assess the originality, academic relevance, methodological rigor, clarity, and contribution of each manuscript to the development of knowledge in Islamic Studies and related disciplines.

02. Peer Review Model

Dirasah employs a double-blind peer review model. Under this system, the identity of the author is not disclosed to reviewers, and the identity of reviewers is not disclosed to authors.

  • Authors must remove identifying information from manuscript files where necessary.
  • Reviewers must not attempt to identify the authors of manuscripts assigned to them.
  • Reviewer identities and review reports are treated as confidential editorial information.
  • The editorial team is responsible for maintaining anonymity throughout the process.

03. Reviewer Selection and Qualifications

Reviewers are appointed by the Editor-in-Chief or the handling editor based on their academic qualifications, research expertise, scholarly experience, and relevance to the subject of the submitted manuscript.

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Have relevant expertise in Islamic Studies, Islamic Education, Islamic Education Management, Education Administration, or related fields within the journal's scope.
  • Provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based evaluations.
  • Disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest.
  • Complete the review within the timeframe agreed upon with the editorial office.
  • Maintain the confidentiality of manuscript materials and review-related information.

04. Review Criteria

Reviewers evaluate manuscripts according to the following academic and editorial criteria:

  • Relevance and Scope: Alignment with the focus and scope of Dirasah.
  • Originality and Contribution: Novelty, significance, and contribution to scholarly knowledge.
  • Literature Review: Relevance, adequacy, and critical engagement with previous studies.
  • Methodological Rigor: Appropriateness, clarity, and validity of research design and methods.
  • Results and Discussion: Accuracy of findings, depth of analysis, and relevance of discussion.
  • Academic Presentation: Organization, clarity, language, and overall manuscript quality.
  • References and Citations: Relevance, accuracy, and adequacy of scholarly sources.

05. Editorial Decisions

Based on reviewers' recommendations and the editor's independent assessment, the journal may issue one of the following decisions:

Accept
The manuscript is accepted for publication without further substantive revision.
Minor Revision
The manuscript requires limited corrections or improvements before acceptance.
Major Revision
The manuscript requires substantial revisions and may be subject to further review.
Reject
The manuscript does not meet the journal's academic standards or publication requirements.

Reviewer recommendations are important considerations but do not automatically determine the publication outcome. The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor.

06. Confidentiality and Ethical Responsibilities

All manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. Reviewers must not disclose, distribute, reproduce, or use unpublished information contained in manuscripts for personal or professional purposes without appropriate authorization.

Reviewers are expected to communicate professionally and respectfully. Personal criticism of authors is not acceptable. All comments and recommendations must focus on academic content, research quality, and scholarly contribution.

The editorial team is responsible for ensuring that the peer review process is conducted fairly and consistently with the journal's publication ethics policies.

07. Conflict of Interest

Reviewers and editors must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may affect their ability to provide an impartial assessment.

A reviewer should decline an invitation if personal, professional, financial, institutional, or collaborative relationships with the authors could compromise their objectivity.

When a conflict of interest is identified, the editorial team will take appropriate measures, including appointing an alternative reviewer when necessary.

08. Review Timeliness

Reviewers are expected to complete their evaluations within the timeframe specified in the review invitation. If a reviewer is unable to complete the review within the agreed period, they should promptly inform the editorial office.

The editorial team monitors the progress of each review and may appoint alternative reviewers when necessary to prevent unreasonable delays in the editorial decision-making process.

09. Plagiarism and Research Integrity

Submitted manuscripts are subject to plagiarism screening before being forwarded for external peer review. The editorial team evaluates potential similarities and other ethical concerns in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies.

Manuscripts involving suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, data falsification, or other forms of research misconduct may be rejected or subjected to further investigation and appropriate editorial action.

10. Appeals and Complaints

Authors may submit a formal appeal if they believe that an editorial decision was based on a significant misunderstanding, factual error, or procedural irregularity.

Appeals must be submitted in writing to the editorial office, providing a clear explanation and relevant supporting evidence. Appeals will be evaluated by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor who was not directly involved in the original decision, where feasible.

Complaints concerning the conduct of editors, reviewers, or the peer review process will be handled confidentially, fairly, and objectively.

11. Post-Review Revisions

Authors receiving a revision decision are required to submit a revised manuscript together with a point-by-point response explaining how each reviewer comment has been addressed.

Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers for further evaluation. However, manuscripts requiring only minor corrections may be assessed directly by the handling editor.

A manuscript will be considered accepted only after the editor is satisfied that the required revisions have been adequately addressed.

12. Final Authority and Policy Implementation

The Editor-in-Chief has overall responsibility for maintaining the quality, fairness, and integrity of the peer review process at Dirasah: International Journal of Islamic Studies.

This policy serves as the journal's framework for editorial evaluation and reviewer conduct. The journal may revise or update this policy when necessary to maintain consistency with recognized standards of scholarly publishing and publication ethics.

Dirasah: International Journal of Islamic Studies
Academic Integrity | Independent Evaluation | Responsible Publishing