JOURNAL EDITORIAL POLICIES
Research Misconduct Policy
Principles and procedures for preventing, identifying, and addressing research misconduct in scholarly publishing.
 

Dirasah: International Journal of Islamic Studies is committed to upholding academic integrity, honesty, transparency, and accountability in all stages of scholarly publishing. The journal expects authors, editors, reviewers, and all parties involved in the publication process to adhere to responsible research and publication practices.

Research misconduct undermines the credibility of academic research and the trustworthiness of scholarly publications. Therefore, Dirasah has established this policy to prevent, identify, investigate, and address suspected cases of research and publication misconduct.

COMMITMENT TO RESEARCH INTEGRITY
Dirasah does not tolerate fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, duplicate publication, or other forms of unethical research and publication practices.
CONTENTS
  1. Definition of Research Misconduct
  2. Types of Research Misconduct
  3. Responsibilities of Authors
  4. Responsibilities of Editors and Reviewers
  5. Detection and Reporting
  6. Investigation Procedures
  7. Editorial Actions and Sanctions
  8. Corrections and Retractions
  9. Confidentiality and Fair Treatment
  10. Prevention of Research Misconduct

01. Definition of Research Misconduct

Research misconduct refers to violations of accepted ethical standards in conducting, reporting, reviewing, and publishing scholarly research. Such violations may compromise the accuracy, originality, reliability, and credibility of research findings.

Research misconduct may occur during the research process, manuscript preparation, submission, peer review, or after publication. Dirasah considers all allegations seriously and handles them through a fair, objective, and confidential process.

02. Types of Research Misconduct

The following practices are considered forms of research or publication misconduct:

Fabrication
Inventing data, results, or research information and presenting them as genuine findings.
Falsification
Manipulating research materials, processes, data, or results in a way that misrepresents the research record.
Plagiarism
Using another person's ideas, words, data, or work without appropriate acknowledgment or attribution.
Duplicate or Redundant Publication
Submitting or publishing substantially the same work in more than one publication without proper disclosure or justification.
Improper Authorship
Including individuals who have not made a legitimate scholarly contribution or excluding individuals who deserve authorship recognition.
Citation Manipulation
Manipulating citations or references to artificially increase citation counts or misrepresent scholarly contributions.
Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest
Failing to disclose relationships or interests that may improperly influence research, review, or editorial decisions.
Unethical Research Practices
Conducting research in violation of applicable ethical requirements, including relevant requirements for research involving human participants or other protected subjects.

The above list is not exhaustive. Other practices that seriously undermine research integrity may also be investigated by the editorial team.

03. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors submitting manuscripts to Dirasah are responsible for ensuring that:

  • The submitted manuscript represents original scholarly work.
  • All sources, ideas, data, and previously published materials are properly acknowledged and cited.
  • Research data and findings are presented accurately and honestly.
  • The manuscript has not been published previously or submitted simultaneously to another journal, except where explicitly permitted and disclosed.
  • All listed authors have made legitimate contributions to the research and have approved the final manuscript.
  • Relevant ethical approvals and permissions have been obtained where required.
  • Any potential conflicts of interest and sources of funding are appropriately disclosed.
  • Any use of generative artificial intelligence is disclosed in accordance with the journal's applicable AI policy.

04. Responsibilities of Editors and Reviewers

Editors and reviewers play an important role in protecting the integrity of scholarly publishing. They are expected to:

  • Evaluate manuscripts fairly, objectively, and independently.
  • Maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and review-related information.
  • Identify and report suspected plagiarism, data manipulation, duplicate publication, or other ethical concerns.
  • Disclose potential conflicts of interest that may affect their judgment.
  • Avoid using unpublished information obtained through the editorial or peer review process for personal advantage.
  • Refer suspected misconduct to the appropriate editorial authority for further assessment.

05. Detection and Reporting

Dirasah may identify suspected research misconduct through plagiarism screening, editorial assessment, peer review, post-publication examination, or reports submitted by readers, authors, reviewers, institutions, or other relevant parties.

Individuals who identify potential research misconduct are encouraged to submit a report to the editorial office. Reports should include a clear explanation of the concern and relevant supporting information or evidence, where available.

All allegations will be assessed carefully. A suspicion or allegation alone does not establish that misconduct has occurred.

06. Investigation Procedures

When a credible allegation of research misconduct is received, the editorial team will conduct an initial assessment to determine whether the concern falls within the scope of this policy and whether further investigation is warranted.

The handling of suspected misconduct may involve the following steps:

  1. Initial Assessment: The editorial team reviews the allegation and available supporting evidence.
  2. Evidence Examination: Relevant manuscript files, publication records, data, and other available information are examined.
  3. Author Communication: The corresponding author may be contacted and given an opportunity to provide an explanation or response.
  4. Further Consultation: Where necessary, the journal may consult relevant experts or the author's affiliated institution.
  5. Editorial Evaluation: The editorial team evaluates the available evidence and determines the appropriate editorial action.
  6. Decision and Documentation: The outcome and actions taken are documented appropriately.

Where the allegation concerns serious institutional or research-related misconduct beyond the journal's authority to investigate, the matter may be referred to the relevant institution or appropriate authority.

07. Editorial Actions and Sanctions

Depending on the nature, seriousness, and evidence of the misconduct, Dirasah may take one or more of the following actions:

  • Request clarification, additional documentation, or correction from the authors.
  • Require revision of the manuscript to address identified concerns.
  • Reject the manuscript before publication.
  • Withdraw a manuscript from the editorial process.
  • Publish a correction, expression of concern, or retraction for an article that has already been published, where justified.
  • Notify the relevant author's institution or other appropriate authority when warranted.
  • Restrict future submissions from authors involved in substantiated serious misconduct, where justified and subject to fair assessment.
Important Note
Editorial actions will be proportionate to the seriousness of the violation and based on the available evidence. Authors will be given an appropriate opportunity to respond before a final decision is made, where feasible.

08. Corrections and Retractions

If significant errors or ethical concerns are identified after publication, Dirasah will evaluate the matter and determine whether a correction, expression of concern, or retraction is necessary.

  • Correction: Issued when an identified error can be corrected without invalidating the overall findings or conclusions of the article.
  • Expression of Concern: Issued when serious concerns require further investigation and the available evidence is not yet sufficient for a final conclusion.
  • Retraction: Considered when substantial problems, such as proven plagiarism, fabricated data, falsified results, or other serious ethical violations, undermine the reliability or integrity of the published work.

Corrections and retractions will be handled transparently, with appropriate notices linked to the affected publication to maintain the integrity of the scholarly record.

09. Confidentiality and Fair Treatment

Dirasah handles allegations of research misconduct with due care, confidentiality, impartiality, and respect for all parties involved. Information related to an investigation will only be shared with individuals who need it for the assessment and resolution of the case.

The journal will avoid premature conclusions and will not treat an allegation as proof of misconduct. Individuals involved will be given a reasonable opportunity to provide relevant explanations or evidence.

The journal also seeks to protect individuals who raise concerns in good faith from retaliation or inappropriate treatment.

10. Prevention of Research Misconduct

Dirasah promotes responsible research and publication practices through clear editorial policies, plagiarism screening, peer review, and communication of publication ethics requirements to authors, editors, and reviewers.

The journal encourages all contributors to:

  • Follow recognized standards of research ethics and academic integrity.
  • Maintain accurate and transparent research records.
  • Provide proper attribution for all sources and contributions.
  • Report research methods and findings honestly and transparently.
  • Comply with the journal's authorship, peer review, conflict of interest, and publication ethics policies.
Dirasah: International Journal of Islamic Studies
Research Integrity | Academic Honesty | Responsible Publishing